add to wish list | library


11 of 11 recommend this,
would you recommend it?

yes | no

 
 
Label:
  Turtle Records - http://www.turtlerecords.com/
Serial:
  TRSA 0029
Title:
  Albéniz: Iberia Vol. 1 - Yoram Ish-Hurwitz
Description:
  Isaac Albéniz: Iberia - Books 1 & 2

Yoram Ish-Hurwitz (piano)
Track listing:
 
Genre:
  Classical - Instrumental
Content:
  Stereo/Multichannel
Media:
  Hybrid
Recording type:
 
Recording info:
 

join discussion | delete from library | delete recommendation | report errors
 
Related titles: 4


 
Reviews: 2
add review

Site review by Geohominid April 29, 2009
Performance:   Sonics:    
The four books of pieces entitled 'Iberia' by Spanish composer Albéniz were written between 1905 and 1909, at a time when the composer was gravely ill. Moving between Paris and Nice, he was recalling his homeland in a series of jewel-like sound-pictures which are impressionistic yet distil the essence of Spanish music. References include regional dances such as jotas, tarantellas, saetas and stamping flamenco. The pianist has to emulate guitar techniques such as 'rasgueo' (strumming) and 'punteo' (plucking), play within a dynamic range of ppppp to fffff and handle technically vertiginous sections which require enormous physical strength and total control. Iberia is one of the greatest (and most beautiful) elements of piano literature, yet because of its almost inhuman difficulties it is comparatively little known.

Yoram Ish-Hurwitz is a young pianist (b. 1968) of Israeli origin who is based in the Netherlands. He was the first Dutch pianist to graduate from the Juilliard School in New York. Extensive preparations have been made for this recording, which is part of a project to play all four books of Iberia at recitals in an extensive concert tour. In the south of Spain he researched the backgrounds and sources of inspiration of the music, filmed by the talented Dutch film maker Jenneke Boeijink. These films will be shown during each recital, alternating with the music, adding a new dimension to the concert experience. The second SACD with the remaining two books of Iberia will be released later in 2009.

Ish-Hurwitz's performance of Iberia is simply remarkable. He has all the technical equipment required to negotiate the most complex and strenuous passages, and a gift for legato, cantabile outlining of melodies which are inflected with the spirit and dialects of Spanish music. All this skill and poetic expression are under superb control, spontaneous-sounding yet meticulously true to the myriad detailed markings which Albéniz applied to his scores. I played this disc alongside the first two books of Hamelin's two-disc set (RBCD, Hyperion) which is regarded as even finer than the classic version by Alicia de Larrocha, and Ish-Hurwitz yields nothing in spectacle, poetry, elegance and grace to Hamelin. Indeed, at times he is even finer; for example in Fête-dieu à Seville from Book 1, he perfectly sustains the long held notes of a majestic melody beneath a scintillating, massive and rapid chordal accompaniment in the treble; the melody flows undisturbed while the brilliant sun overhead glitters and gleams impressively, as it were. Hamelin, however, has the accompanying treble figurations too loud, and the melody beneath is almost lost. Ish-Hurwitz's phenomenal control not only evokes the vibrant life-essence of the Spanish locations and celebrations conjured by Albéniz, but is fully in service of the delicate impressionistic poetry of these pieces, in which the influence of Debussy is so clear.

This thrilling pianism is matched by a recording which is awesome - an adjective which I rarely use. The Steinway D was in the famous custom studio suite at Mol, Belgium. The buildings are suspended on massive springs which remove all LF noise, producing a noise-free 'black' acoustic for recording. Turtle engineers recorded in DXD and mastered in DSD with Sonodore mics and preamps. Within a supportive ambience (especially in MC), the fidelity of reproduction is breathtaking, with no pedal or action noises. Full attention is given to the enormous dynamic range. Albéniz frequently requires the pedal to be held for bars at a time, and one can hear the Steinway tone developing for several seconds after the keys are pressed. The harmonics are clearly heard, as is their damping when the pedal comes off. Ish-Hurwitz also voices his chords carefully, so that one or more notes register more than others, adding subtle nuances to the music. The powerful rich bass and tonal range of this piano, as recorded, are a perfect marriage for this mercurial yet poetic performance. Hamelin's piano, on one of Hyperion's good RBCD discs, sounds flat and puny in direct comparison.

I suspect it will be some time before another performance will emerge to challenge Hamelin, de Larrocha and now Ish-Hurwitz in 'Iberia' . The sonics of this SACD themselves already outclass rivals by some distance, and to hear this gorgeous, brilliant and life-affirming suite in one's own home is a privilege. I can't wait to hear Books 3 & 4, perhaps with some extra music as on the rival discs; my only quibble is that some people may think that just over 40 mins is very short measure (and the Turtle package is silent about the running time).

Copyright © 2009 John Miller and SA-CD.net

Review by jeff3948 April 5, 2010 (3 of 3 found this review helpful)
Performance:   Sonics:    
Yoram Ish-Hurwitz's strength is his subtlety of phrasing which shows his love for Albeniz's music. According to his website, Yoram Ish-Hurwitz spent time in Spain studying and preparing this work and it shows in the results because the performance comes across in an effortless and convincing way. I don't know if it's fair to compare this young artist with the great Alicia De Larrocha 3rd recording made in 1986 , but it does seem fitting to do so. I found that Ms. De Larrocha's accents are a little crisper as well has her contrasts more extreme and playing a little more flamboyant and intense. This is shown in Book 2, "Almería". One gets the impression that this music is in Ms. De Larrocha's blood whereas Mr. Ish-Hurwitz sounds like a foreigner that has mastered the language but does not quit have the accent down yet, or perhaps he simply takes a slightly more relaxed view point. Ms. De Larrocha's lived with this music much longer before she recorded it her 3rd time than Mr. Ish-Hurwitz has in his first, so she does have an advantage. But that is not to say that Mr. Ish-Hurwitz's is not enjoyable. He is very enjoyable too and has done exceedingly well. Also, his recording has the advantage of being a sumptuous multi-channel SACD which was a joy to my ears. The only minor drawback to the recording is a lack of ambiance (reverberation) that a good concert hall would give to a recording. Also, this studio recording gives it a somewhat narrower dynamic range compared to Ms. De Larrocha's recording, however, it could be caused by their difference in playing. (FYI - Ms. De Larrocha's recording was made by John Dunkerley in the Concert Hall, University Music Hall, Cambridge). It would be interesting to compare Herve Billaut's new SACD of this same work with both Mr. Ish-Hurwitz and Ms. De Larrocha. Overall, this is a very beautiful and satisfying SACD. I highly recommend it.

Was this review helpful to you?  yes | no

 
Works: 2  

Isaac Albeniz - Iberia (Book 1)
Isaac Albeniz - Iberia (Book 2)