|
Site review by Polly Nomial February 22, 2010
|
Performance: Sonics (MC): |
A phenomenal conclusion to this excellent cycle.
Compared to Schumann: Symphonies Nos. 3 & 4 - Foster, this is a breath of fresh air and wonderfully dramatic. By using a chamber orchestra, Dausgaard is not only able to reveal details easily but he is able to do this at speeds that would be quite impossible with most full-size symphony orchestras. To illustrate how much faster his tempo choices are, the Foster accounts of the symphonys come in a full 9 minutes slower than here (and Dausgaard omits no repeats). Only in one movement, the Feierlich of the 3rd symphony, does one feel that perhaps it is a little too quick but the doubt is marginal and placed in context of the whole sweep of the performance works well indeed.
The attention given to accents and dynamics and the dialogue within the orchestra (aided by split violins) is exemplary and recalls the astonishment that I felt when hearing Beethoven played like this for the first time. In accounts like these and with such glorious playing, Mahler's assertion for the need to re-orchestrate looks very foolish indeed. Added to these marvellously well played symphonies are two overtures - both very deserving of being better known and given suitably accomplished performances. The longer is that to Manfred and is arguably the finer work - it is more overtly dramatic and has a powerful undercurrent surging beneath the surface.
The sound is fully up to the best of the house sound and should disappoint no-one. Clarity, smoothness and air sum up the attributes best and could easily pass as a demonstration disc for the artists, label or indeed the type of music making itself.
Highly recommended along with the other 2 discs; a compulsory purchase for all Schumann fans.
(Purchased.)
|
Copyright © 2010 John Broggio and SA-CD.net
|
|
