| Judging a rescord by its cover (review from amazon.com) |
|
Notorious Byrd Brothers is a great record, though as Mr Goodwin notes, the recording is kind of muddy. I bought this SACD recording on Mr Goodwin's recommendation. He will not want to meet me for a few weeks. The Mobile Fidelity SACD issue is frankly no better in any way than the Columbia Legacy stereo mix. And if you can hear any difference between the mono and Stereo mixes, then you are concentrating 100% on every note being played, and probably being victimized by your imagination. The cover says the record is SACD. So you should expect a better quality of sound on SACD equipment. NOPE. That is not what you get. On my SACD Pioneer player, the "SACD" sound is no better than the Columbia Legacy issue. A mono mix that is really the same as the stereo. And a sound that SACD did not improve. And an attractive cover. That is what you get when you buy this.
|
|
| Righteous Rockers Get The MFSL Treatment (review from amazon.com) |
|
| The Gold CD version of THE NOTORIOUS BYRD BROTHERS gives the Byrds the Super Audio CD treatment, which is a wonderful idea, especially since the band always had very crystalline production values. This version brings "Goin' Back", a song of longing for childhood which acknowledges that you can't ever really go home again, and "Triad", which were in competition for a spot on the original album, together for the first time. With this album, the Byrds also started moving toward a country-rock sound and style. The surviving members' opposition to Indonesia's trumped-up 2005 drug-smuggling conviction of a young Australian tourist makes this Gold CD an essential purchase for both your ears AND your conscience.
|
|
| Great album, and a huge step forward for MFSL (review from amazon.com) |
|
(Note: this is more of a review of this specific reissue than a review of the album "The Notorious Byrd Brothers." Needless to say, the album is fantastic...but those just looking to grab the record should look for the stock Legacy reissue. This Mobile Fidelity mono hybrid SACD is made for a specific crowd, as is this review)
I have to say that I haven't been spectacularly captivated by "new-phase" Mobile Fidelity. I did, however, make a pledge that if MoFi suddenly started releasing stuff that was interesting--stuff otherwise unavailable on CD, for example, which is how I saw them remaining relevant in the current music market--I would eagerly bite.
Well, with the mono Byrds discs, they have delivered something interesting, and as I'm a man of my informally-expressed internet word, I picked up this hybrid SACD of "Notorious." So how is this second entry in Mobile Fidelity's foray into the world of the Byrds?
Packaging: Okay. Not quite premium, which is disappointing given how expensive these things are. MoFi increased the size of their usual postage-stamp covers, but c'mon...do we still really need that design? The booklet seems to be a variation on the booklet included in the standard Sony package, only slightly blurrier, with little "mono" annotations and the mastering credits replaced.
The blurb on the shrink wrap is also interesting, as it implies that these mono mixes are from 1969 (aka a year after the album's release). Huh?
That said, MoFi's packaging has never been amazing, so perhaps this is an unfair area of criticism...
The sound: Excellent, for what it is: a great transfer of a somewhat muddy mix from a sort of shaky source, this nonetheless represents a really nice variation of this album on CD. For those who are wondering, this DOES seem to be an alternate mono mix. The differences are pretty subtle, though; some I've noticed thus far are less-pronounced horns on "Artificial Energy" (on "Till I'll be up in the sky"...the tape for this song, by the way, is pretty chewed), and a more-pronounced vocal effect on "Change Is Now" (which STILL has a slight fade-up). Edits and segues are also a bit different.
The stereo bonus tracks are NOT new transfers, but are derived (at least partly) from the transfers used to prepare the Sony reissue. This is unsurprising, and as these should be properly viewed as "extra content"--i.e. stuff that Sony likely mandated be included--I don't see this as a big problem.
Verdict? It's nice to see MoFi embark on a more esoteric path, but the super-premium price for a product that...isn't really super premium (re. artwork, etc.) still rankles. It's also unfortunate that "Brothers" isn't one of the more fascinating alternate mono mixes in the Byrds pantheon, but that isn't MoFi's fault. That said, if you can get a discount that pushes this into a more reasonably priced category, it's a great curio that hopefully signals the release of more similar, niche items in the future. Mono Dylan, perhaps?
|
|
