|
Site review by Polly Nomial January 13, 2009
|
Performance: Sonics (MC): |
A wonderful disc of some of the best duo playing (guitar or otherwise) that one could wish to hear.
Apart from the central Tango Suite, all the works here have been arranged by the Katona Twins. Most feature the Carducci String Quartet and Daniel Storer on double-bass but there is also a guest appearance by Alfredo Marcucci on the bandoneón. All protagonists play with a real vigour and passion that makes one convinced that all the pieces were written for the duo (and friends).
Whilst this music does not have the sophistication of say a Mozart sonata, it is far removed from the transient, disposable world of what is dubbed "pop culture". Much of the music is very enjoyable and memorable indeed and has an poignantly anguished element that is unusual in "lighter" fare. Having visited Buenos Aires, it is remarkable how adeptly that Piazzola captures the sole of the city and perhaps more remarkable how well these Hungarian guitarists and British string players (Marcucci is of course a native of Buenos Aires) reflect the style of playing of the tango in this great metropolis. It is all to easy to find oneself tapping along (crudely!) to the seductive rhythms...
The engineering from Channel Classics is absolutely first-rate. The scale is absolutely perfect and one can imagine reaching out and handing the players refreshments in the hope that the recital would continue some more - sadly, one is bought back to reality after nearly an hour of pure escapist bliss.
Highly enjoyable and recommended enthusiastically.
|
Copyright © 2009 John Broggio and SA-CD.net
|
|
|
Review by georgeflanagin July 5, 2006 (5 of 6 found this review helpful)
|
Performance: Sonics (S): |
Piazzolla has become something of a celebrity composer in the past few years. Thirty years ago, I made it through two semesters of music history without hearing anything about him except for his name. This album has a good sampling of Piazzolla's small scale music, although ... only one piece on this disc was actually written for the forces that play it. If you like guitar, this will be an appealing arrangement. If you are after The Real Thing in Piazzolla, it may not.
The playing is clean. The sound is natural, to the point where it passes the LIAR test.** The recording serves the music very well. Most good hifis will produce satisfying sound when the instruments being reproduced are guitar, string quartet, and bandoneon, which is exactly what we have here. Channel Classics showed admirable restraint in keeping this recording within the bounds of good taste: you feel like you have a good seat in a small venue, not one with your left ear on the sound hole of one guitar, and your right ear on the other.
I played this album a couple of times a week when I first bought it; less so now. It is a good introduction to music from Piazzolla's part of the world in the mid-20th century. Piazzolla's music is less complex than Villa-Lobos, and more melodically memorable. In other words, much of this music is something that you find yourself able to sing along with.
At 55 minutes, the price is a little steep for the market niche served: a sampler of music by Piazzolla, arranged by the artists for performance with their chosen "two guitars, et al." format. On the other hand, because I have little acoustic guitar music in the piles, I am able to play something for guests who are curious, and who like guitar.
The best cuts are 4-6, which form the "Tango Suite for Two Guitars," and I like #7, which is "Tres Minutos con la Realidad."
** LIAR test: Coined by some audio magazine years ago, it is the Listening In Another Room test. In other words, if you hear the sound down a hallway do you feel the need to peek in the door to see if it is a live performance.
|
Was this review helpful to you?
|
|
