|
Site review by Castor June 19, 2005
|
Performance: Sonics (S/MC): / |
This is an interesting coupling of two romantic piano concertos. The Chopin is familiar through countless versions whereas the Loewe was previously unknown (at least to me).
Maria Kodema’s account of the Chopin begins with a finely played orchestral introduction by the RNO, with no sense of routine. I particularly liked the clear bass lines here. When the soloist enters one is aware that the piano is quite closely balanced, but not so much as to hide the excellent woodwind solos including a nice woody sounding bassoon. Overall I found Maria Kodema’s playing to be sensitive and poetic without perhaps showing the imagination of say Rubinstein (now available in the Living Stereo series) or the distinctiveness of Zimerman is his (second) version on DGG.
The first movement of the Loewe begins somewhat disconcertingly with the conductor (?) vocalising the rhythm (dah dah da dah) of the opening theme but overall it does not disturb for long. In this tuneful work the piano is kept busy most of the time with passage-work and the orchestra is relegated to a supportive role.
The delightful slow movement begins with a piano solo that sounds like the introduction to a song. It is subtitled ‘Espaniola’ but it does not sound particularly Spanish. If Rossini had written a piano concerto then this movement could be from it.
The lively rondo finale completes what is a thoroughly entertaining work, even if it is not a forgotten masterpiece, and I cannot imagine it being played better than on this disc. Anyone who has been collecting Hyperion’s ‘The Romantic Piano Concerto’ series on RBCD will not fail to enjoy this piece.
The DSD recording of both works is splendid, and Erdo Groot has captured the acoustic of the Moscow Conservatory and the characterful playing of the orchestra with his usual skill. The MC sound is all one could wish for.
|
Copyright © 2005 Graham Williams and SA-CD.net
|
|
