5 of 5 recommend this SA-CD
Would you recommend it?

 

(Prices subject to change)
 
Label:
  Fantasy - http://www.fantasyjazz.com/
Serial:
  JZSA-946-6
Title:
  Thelonious Monk with John Coltrane
Description:
  "Thelonious Monk with John Coltrane"

Thelonious Monk
John Coltrane
Details:
  1. Ruby, My Dear
2. Trinkle, Tinkle
3. Off Minor
4. Nutty-Monk
5. Epistrophy
6. Functional
Genre:
  Jazz
Content:
  Stereo
Media:
  Hybrid
Recording type:
 
Recording info:
 

start discussion | delete from library | delete recommendation | report errors
 
Related titles: 15 show all


 
Reviews: 5 show all

Review by Croc April 27, 2005 (0 of 2 found this review helpful)
Sonics:
for me this disc is a mixed bag.
sonics is far from what i used to get from Fantasy's SACDs.
3 out of 6 tracks can be found on "Monk's musik" SACD.
but the last track is beatiful.

Was this review helpful to you?
 

Review by JW August 22, 2004
Performance:  Sonics:
This great album brings together Monk, Coltrane and Hawkins, plus Art Blakey on drums. So who are Ray Copeland, Gigi Gryce and Wilbur Ware ? A few words on each of them - just to add a different angle to the reviews here:

Gryce played altosax beween 1950 and 1960. He retired from the jazz scene to dedicate himself to teaching. He played with Lionel Hampton, Oscar Pettiford and Donald Byrd.

Copeland played trumpet and is considered a composer and instructor spanning a period of 40 years (1940-1980). He played with Al Kooper, Blakey and Louis Bellson to name but a few.

Ware was considered to be on a similar level as Pettiford and Blanton. A very influential bass player. He played from the 40's to the 60's - a period where he suffered health problems - and into the 70's, working with Eldridge, Rollins and others and recording for Blue Note and Riverside as a sideman.

Sonically I concur with the others who gave it a three star rating. What makes listening to Monk so interesting ? Try this: spin some Bill Evans and afterwards switch to Monk. I love Evans, but Monk is so much more interesting and surprising in his treatment of melody and chord changes. There is more experiment and counterpoints there, while Evans keeps it all nicely on track. Different styles, both masters of their trade, but Monk presents you with more of the unexpected. A continuing source of musical discovery.

Jw

Was this review helpful to you?
 

Review by FivePointOne July 21, 2004
Performance:  Sonics:
Here's another review solely on the sonics. I was really surprised at how little this SACD is an improvement over the previously issued CD. Normally, the piano comes out much cleaner and realistic in SACD than in standard redbook. Unfortunately, that's not quite the rule with this title. The track "Functional" is a perfect example. Fantasy could/should have done a much better job with this SACD.

Was this review helpful to you?