| Site review by Polly Nomial November 10, 2007
|
Performance: Sonics (MC): |
A stunning début from Martin Helmchen that in its own way is even more impressive than Julia Fischer's was those few years back.
Firstly, a definite nod in the direction of the Netherlands Chamber Orchestra should be made - the direction from Gordon Nikolic; is nothing less than inspired. From a darkly luxuriant texture of the C minor concerto to the brilliantly Beethovenian weight of the C major concerto, all the players are fully alive to the expressive potential in all the music. Special mention must go to the woodwind principals at the gorgeous conclusion to the Larghetto of No.24 but it would be invidious to suggest that their colleagues are not on the same exalted musical level.
Next up is the playing of Helmchen - he can only be compared to the likes of Perahia and not unfavourably so. The delicacy of his touch, richness of tone and the details that he extracts from the piano are a joy to the ear and the soul alike. Make no mistake, for this is no HIP interpretation but far from being a carbon copy of the golden greats of yesteryear - more that Helmchen has captured the spirit but clothed it in modern garb. The one and only criticism I can level is his choice of cadenza for No. 24 - for me, good though he is as a pianist, Lars Vogt's cadenza is not as convincing musically as others have been (it is as though he runs out of ideas for the first movement and then thinks "ah yes, broken octaves - that'll excite people!") Tempi throughout are nigh on ideal, as is the balance between piano and orchestra; the dovetailing and batting about of motifs is very exciting and a wonder to behold.
The sound is every bit as fitting as the playing and one can have no reservations about the piano as it is recorded here. Indeed it is so good, that one completely fails to think about it during the playing and it is only on reflection that it becomes a consideration.
Fantastic stuff & more Mozart please!
|
Copyright © 2007 John Broggio and SA-CD.net
|
|
|
| Site review by Castor April 5, 2008
|
Performance: Sonics (MC): |
In March of last year, when Martin Helmchen was a member of the BBC New Generation Artists programme, I attended a concert at the BBC studios in Manchester in which he played Liszt’s 2nd Piano Concerto. On that occasion, I was impressed not just by his panache in the showy virtuoso passages but also by his poetic and sensitive playing in the more reflective passages of the work. Here, in his debut disc for PentaTone, he plays two works of a less technically challenging nature but which require more intellectual acuity and the result is in every way a triumphant success.
From the first few bars of the opening ritornello it is apparent that this performance of K491 is to be a weighty affair and the drama inherent in the music is immediately established. Helmchen’s first entry is surprisingly gentle and restrained, but he quickly moves on to give a beautifully poised performance that lacks nothing in authority, even when compared with the many distinguished versions of this concerto available on CD. The recording vividly captures every detail of Mozart’s orchestration; the richest he had ever employed in a concerto, and it is a real pleasure to be able to savour the superb wind playing of the Netherlands Chamber Orchestra. Martin Helmchen plays a cadenza in the first movement by his friend Lars Vogt lasting 1’47” which, though no worse than many written by other pianists, is still too long. Eric Blom aptly described such cadenzas as “pretentious excrescences”.
It was a particularly happy idea to couple the great C minor concerto K491 with the earlier C major work K415 as the latter has always been something of a Cinderella among the canon of Mozart piano concertos. Martin Helmchen’s spirited performance of this essentially amiable work is a joy from beginning to end, while the deft accompaniment from the Netherlands Chamber Orchestra directed by Gordon Nickolic is a model of its kind. The performance is full of felicities, for example the way in which Helmchen makes the most of the contrast between the doleful C minor episodes in the final Rondeau and the movement’s cheerful opening theme.
The pellucid sound quality of the spacious PentaTone recording adds enormously to one’s enjoyment of these performances and this outstanding disc can be warmly recommended without reservation.
|
Copyright © 2008 Graham Williams and SA-CD.net
|
|
|
| Review by Windsurfer October 12, 2007 (14 of 14 found this review helpful)
|
Performance: Sonics (S/MC): / |
This one is rather special! Superb sound; and the very nuanced but masculine playing from Helmchen and the Netherlands Chamber Orchestra is wonderful! Not a period performance, but like Julia Fischer's Mozart Concertos, this is a period informed performance of the highest caliber.
I was unfamiliar with the concerto #13 and found it to be a joyful experience. The great C minor concerto is authoritatively played and while this disc doesn't completely erase my desire for a Bruno Walter type accompaniment for this concerto, it is a disc I will listen to repeatedly because it is quite compelling!
I actually listened to this first in stereo last night on my upstairs system over the Celestion SL6si loudspeakers. I was quite impressed. But this morning in multi-channel on the big system downstairs, I was amazed at the detail, the spaciousness, the clarity and purity of the piano sound, and the playing of the Netherlands Chamber Orchestra, to say nothing of the interpretive sophistication and utterly clean articulation of Martin Helmchen!
This is a winner, a real winner!
|
Was this review helpful to you?
|
|
|
| Review by Domimag October 27, 2007 (10 of 12 found this review helpful)
|
Performance: Sonics (S/MC): / |
Listened on multi-channel (5.0) :
Again PentaTone give us a marvellous recorded SACD. I agree with "windsurfer" for the very beautiful piano and orchestra sound. This is clear with a very good stereo "picture". The level between piano and orchestra is, for my taste, perfect. I just find the strings "tutti" a little "sharp" sometimes but... that is a "chamber orchestra" and the sound don't bother my taste.
Helmchen is a very good pianist, no doubt ! It is his first but I hope not the last SACD he records for PentaTone. I would like very much if he records all the great Mozart piano concertos !
The C minor 24th concerto is well done with good tempo. This 24th was often played by Beethoven. I have Perahia and Serkin-Abbado versions (CD). I'm sure I'll now listen very often Helmchen-Nikolic.
For the 13th I never heard it played by anybody. So I have no reference about it but it is, for me, quite compelling and a nice discover.
Bravo Helmchen, Nikolic and the Netherlands Chamber Orchestra !
Lille (France) - 10/27/2007
edit : sound too much "dry" and "hard" on strings when listening stereo (SACD and CD)
|
Was this review helpful to you?
|
|
|
| Review by JJ November 20, 2007 (6 of 7 found this review helpful)
|
Performance: Sonics (S/MC): / |
Composed for two violins, cello and bass, two oboes, two bassoons, two French horns, C trumpet, as well as C and G kettledrums, Mozart’s Piano Concerto N° 13 in C major K. 415 is part of what Michel Parouty calls "the three concertos offered by subscription that the composer himself played with great success during his ‘Academy’ of March 22, 1783. It is more audacious than its two companions. Not only is the instrumentation richer (the winds therein are of greater importance, even if no soloist theme is given to them), but the writing, which counts largely on counterpoint, bears the trace of the recent revelation of the old masters Bach and Hændel ." Insofar as Concerto N° 24 in C minor K. 491, it’s instrumentation is also undeniably rich. For his first Pentatone recording, the young pianist Martin Helmchen delights us with a small miracle of interpretation that the public no longer expects in an often recorded work. Accompanied by a committed orchestra and conductor, Helmchen offers the freshness of a lively, colorful and impassioned approach. The fluidity of his playing obeys a musical discourse that is both profound and calm. Our attention never wanes, and his pleasure winds up confounding our own. In an ideal stereo and multi-channel recording, this SACD, accompanied by a DVD presenting the pianist, is a welcome surprise.
Jean-Jacques Millo
Translation Lawrence Schulman
|
Was this review helpful to you?
|
|
|
