| Review by robstl February 18, 2006 (7 of 7 found this review helpful)
|
Performance: Sonics (MC): |
I greatly enjoyed this. I haven't heard the Pletnev, yet, which Polly Nomial has reviewed for the site. The Rostropovich, Lazarev, and Kitajenko readings are all in my player, and if forced to do so, I'd probably pick Kitajenko because of the sound and the orchestra. The sound on Caetani's is close in but natural, with a reasonable amount of hall resonance in the surround speakers that I find involving without being distracting. It isn't quite as convincing as Kitajenko's sound.
This reading is fairly conventional in its pacing; the first movement is just a bit faster than average (15'18"), but unlike in the Caetani 8th, it doesn't feel rushed, and the phrases flow nicely. The orchestra, as in the other recordings I've heard from them, is gritty and powerful. The massacre depicted in the second movement is devastating. The hammered triplets in the third movement are memorable. The fourth movement is exciting...
...and wait 'til you hear those bells at the end! Every performance I've heard before this one has used orchestral chimes. This one, by contrast, either uses real, deep live church bells (how would they fit them on stage??) or an excellent facsimile -- perhaps they were prerecorded, or somehow synthesized? They are incredible. Your dog will be scared. Your neighbors will be scared. Tyrants will shake in their shoes. My reaction was similar to the first time I heard Tchaikovsky's 1812 with church bells instead of orchestral chimes. I find it hard to go back to the chimes! The well-deserved applause is left in at the end.
Another excellent 11th on SA-CD!
|
Was this review helpful to you?
|
|
